Thursday, September 1, 2011

Who Are the Elite?

Democracy, we must spread it. Capitalism, we must enforce it. Freedoms, we must preach them. Rarely do we, as Americans, believe that we should change to fit others ways. In a culture where we BELIEVE to be superior, who truly are the elite?

Elitists can be traced throughout history, starting with the beginning of time; from arrogant kings and Jews in the Bible, to well-known philosophers and wars, elitists have tried, and many times succeeded, in changing others ways. Americans specifically have had numerous attempts to spread varying beliefs. The Manifest Destiny in the 19th century gave reason to expand across the continent of North America, but who says we have stopped? Expansion may not be continental, but surely we continue to conquer the minds and beliefs of other people.

Continue on now to the problems facing us today. Not only do we enforce our beliefs onto other countries and cultures, we ensure their immediate success with power and threats. What happens after that is not our problem, because until recently, the façade of perfection was one aspect that many people believed. Even now that our flaws are blatant and glaring we still believe that with our power and “money” we will come out on top. Our government is of the opinion that money and resources are infinite, therefore conveying a false sense of superiority.


The Price family in The Poisonwood Bible believed that not only was their religion superior, but their thoughts were as well. Reverend Price, a Baptist minister, and his family attempted to convert many Congolese people during the 1960’s. Not only did the Congolese reject many teachings, they also rejected many ways of western thinking. Questions such as why majority rules, and how come sharing is not a virtue for Americans were brought up through the people of the village of Kilanga. The author, Barbara Kingsolver slightly satirized the western beliefs by illustrating the hardships the family suffered through by using American customs and beliefs in a war-torn, dusty village in the Congo.

Who was right? Are elitists who we think they are? This word must either change definition over time, or the people must change their beliefs on this word. This cannot be simple.

2 comments:

  1. A most impressive blog, Laura! You sound like a Historian, and certainly elitism is a critical issue that several authors address. I am wondering whether or not you have experienced negative encounters with "the elite." I'm also curious about your definition of what Elitists "think they are." Good luck pursuing a most intriguing question!

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is a very good question! People have been debating this for years and history classes still debate the thinking of who was/is the elite today. Good luck! This is not an easy question to discuss because of the thousands of different opinions on the topic.

    ReplyDelete